City to Renegotiate It's Lease with B&G Club

Not a done deal-yet: "Divert" Green Acres Status, renegotiate 50-year Lease agreement with the B&G, HoLa can apply for Variance to expand

What a week! GA was hosting guests from out-of-town (way out-of-town)--Osaka, Japan.

I took this photo on Saturday.  Against the harsh forces of winter, a few cherry blossoms had sprouted from an otherwise barren tree.

GA admires those rugged little flowers. 

Given warmth, rich soil and bright sun, all flowers may flourish.  Deprive them, and only the rugged survive.

Flowers are like children.

Let's re-cap.  Here is what we have learned recently about Hoboken's Boys & Girls Club:

The membership fee has gone from $15/year to $65 week; that is $2, 860 for 44 weeks of the program (not including 8 weeks of summer camp).  That amounts to an annual increase of $2,795 per child.

GA hears this fee hike has caused  B&G Club kids to leave "in droves".

We've also learned the B&G Club Director is Margarita Garcia, who is on the Faculty & Staff of HoLa as the school's AfterCare and Enrollment Coordinator. 

We know that the Boys and Girl's Club has been sub-leasing their space to HoLa, Dual Language School, which makes B&G Director/HoLa Staff member Garcia landlord and tenant of the space the B&G leases from Hoboken for $2/year. 

Screen caps: 12/15/2014

A GA reader posted the HoLa Aftercare and Enrichment classes rates.  

If those rates are accurate, then sub-lessee HoLa is a regular cash cow for the B&G Club. 

Or is it?  B&G Director Garcia can ask the HoLa Aftercare Coordinator Garcia.

Perhaps B&G Director Garcia can negotiate with HoLa's Aftercare Coordinator Garcia to allot space in the "Enrichment classes" for economically disadvantaged B&G kids and/or kids priced out of B&G club membership, since taxpayers subsidize the building for $2/year.

Oh, one more thing: 123 Jefferson was built with Green Acres public funding and the presence of the Charter is an apparent violation to the Green Acres rules. 

In August 2011 MSV wrote, in part:
The Hoboken Boys and Girls Club has failed to provide required annual reports to the City of Hoboken showing specific compliance requirements serving the community's underprivileged youth. The terms of the agreement are part of a fifty year lease originally created back in the mid 90s.

The complete terms appear in an original ordinance dated November 1994 in City documents. As part of a 50 year agreement, the building at 123 Jefferson Street is leased annually from the City of Hoboken for $2.

The original ordinance states a requirement of the lessee (the Boys & Girls Club) to the City of Hoboken in item 10:

The Lessee agrees to use the facilities for the sole purpose of conducting youth programs and the Lessee activities. It will not rent or lease the facility for commercial purposes without first obtaining City permission nor will any commercial activities be conducted at the facility.

Meanwhile, the building is expanding - to benefit the HoLa school...

Questions on the authorization of these activities and the City's oversight and approval role in the process remains outstanding. Complaints have been going on for months among public school parents including other charter schools on the unfair competitive advantage of a charter school being hosted at the Boys & Girls Club while underprivileged community youth have been bumped out of the building to make way for HoLa.
That was 2011; what's happening now?     

GA has learned the City is on track to "divert" Green Acres status from 123 Jefferson to 16th Street, then re-negotiate its "50 year lease agreement" with the Boys and Girls Club with two parties: the B&G and HoLa.  

I kid you not. The City's 50-year lease to agreement with the Boy's and Girl's Club of America to use the facilities for the sole purpose of conducting youth programs and the Lessee activities is to be canned so the taxpayer-funded building at 123 Jefferson can legally host an expanding Charter school, with its upscale demographic. Of course, all this is contingent upon "diverting" Green Acres status from the site.  

On September 17 2014, the City Council voted 8-0 in favor of the Resolution below (Castellano was absent):


Now, read Section 6b of the Tripartite Agreement Hoboken Boys and Girls Club, HOLA, and the City of Hoboken carefully, keeping in mind that Director Garcia is BOTH Parties: HOLA and BGC:
b. Neither HOLA nor BGC may assign, transfer or delegate any of its rights or obligations hereunder without obtaining the prior written consent of the other Parties, which may be withheld for any reason, whether reasonable or unreasonable.
If the City is determined to re-purpose a taxpayer-funded building intended to benefit poor youth and youth programs to a Charter school catering to an upscale demographic (oh yeah, it does...  check out the fees on the "Enrichment classes"), GA implores the City to use it's leverage to negotiate rights for the children of the Boys and Girls Club, including use of facilities and reduced membership fees. 


  1. Its called gentrification. you think anyone gives a shit about the poor of this city? Take a look at the generators rotting in the parking lot.

  2. So it's a done deal? Hola is now on the lease and can use the building anyway it wants? It can expand it fit it's growing popultation but there was no cnsideration or protection for the previous Boys & Girls population? Really? What happened to the 15 community meeting about taking this important and needed community resource offline? Sad.

    1. No, the lease has not been changed- yet.

      I believe the Green Acres status needs to be "diverted" from 123 Jefferson first before the City can legally lease the building directly to HoLa (and the B&G Club). Then, the application would go to the Zoning Board for the height variance at 123 Jefferson.

      Read the 'Tripartite" agreement in the embedded resolution. With the resolution, the City Council authorizes the mayor to apply to the Zoning Board for a height variance on behalf of HoLa subject to execution of said "Tripartite" agreement. The "Tripartite" agreement subsumes a renegotiated lease between the City and the "two parties": HoLa and the BGC.

      Gotta love that Section 6: "Neither HOLA nor BGC may assign, transfer or delegate any of its rights or obligations hereunder without obtaining the prior written consent of the other Parties...

      You mean, B&G Director Garcia is free to transfer the B&G's rights, obligations, etc. to HoLa's Aftercare Coordinator Garcia, but only if she obtains the written consent of herself to herself? You can't make this shit up.

    2. So technically, Hola's tenacy is illegal.

      "Neither HOLA nor BGC may assign, transfer or delegate any of its rights or obligations hereunder without obtaining the prior written consent of the other Parties...
      The city created this lease. They can change it. Seems the city removed themselves from any authorization for rental and subleasing.

  3. I don't know what all the fuss is about rec space. Doesn't everyone have a playroom in their four story home or a swimming pool or community room in their highrise with pool table and large screen tv's. geesh.

  4. Dawn Zimmer, incompetence and pandering since 2007. Governing by headlines and diary notes

    1. Blaming the mayor is an easy out for the B&G Club, isn't it? I would credit them with emptying the building with that $2,795 fee hike.

      Solutions start with bringing the kids back, and keeping the rec facilities available to them, and leaving the Green Acres status where it is.

      Props to Zimmer for exposing Christie, but that is not the topic of this discussion.

    2. City can't keep green acres there. Green acres does not allow limited access. Hola would have to vacate the premesis for green acres to remain.

    3. The city can keep Green Acres there. Anon @ 9:39am gave the answer. The Charter sublease was a violation from the get-go.

    4. Hola vacate? Never happen

  5. Does Garcia even have anything more than a High School diploma? Ever hear her speak?
    Forget Spanish or English. She speaks like ghetto trash

  6. DestinnezDave must love this plan... helping a charter and expunging minorities... next stop the hha

  7. In the broader sense, HoLa's presence at the Boys and Girls Club is a two-fer. By granting HoLa its charter when it doesn't qualify as one and then approving its expansion, another charter school is formed. The ultimate goal of the most conservative Republicans is the privatization of the public school system, which has long been a plank in their platform. Charter schools are a step along that path. By disenfranchising African-American kids, they continue to marginalize a population who almost never votes Republican, which is part of the new Jim Crow laws they keep passing.

    By making it possible for a valuable city owned asset to be transferred from those who need it the most to those who need it the least, Zimmer is only pandering to her perceived base which is white families with kids.

    It's very curious that the National B&G Club hasn't paid Zimmer a visit, and It's surprising that the club's kids parents haven't expressed outrage. I don't believe that the transfer of the building to HoLa was legal when they moved in and I don't believe this de-facto sale is legal either.

  8. Hey Anon. Don't forget a certain blowhard/ multi-job, lazy ass , public education backstabber's quest for a 3 Bedroom condo on the cheap. It's that person's Destiny to have a Bedroom for each Child!

  9. Funny how we still have a little bit of the old Hoboken way of doing things a live and well when the wives and relatives of Hoboken politicos get these job$.

  10. Can't wait to see Mello pander to his white friends and his hopes for DaVinci ( no free lunch ) Charter School. All while he evokes the Bronx and his sob story that he's a teacher there...

  11. Mr Mello just came out tonight with the revelation that he takes street parking while not using the private garage in his building intended for it's residents. So public free parking is okay to take, but he won't take advantage of Hoboken Public Schools

    1. off-topic anonymous personal attacks get you nowhere.


Post a Comment